- Published on
So, just who do you think you are, eh?
In preparing for my career I learned the psychological theories of what goes into an individual’s unique character. There was my university coursework on personality theory. Then there was learning theory and how external contingencies influence behaviour. All of this looked at the individual from outside, following a path of development, altered along the way by its engagement with context. Back then the debate was about nature and nurture … as if there was nothing else to even consider.
Over the course of my career adverse childhood experiences and attachment styles were recognized as powerful contributors to what would become the typical functioning of the individual.
As I went through my paces in clinical psychology, the objective was on treating symptoms so the client could return to their normal self. This presumed there was a normal self, something, once formed, that remained pretty well set for life.
Interesting word that: self. Psychology really didn’t like it very much. Let’s identify it as the subjective sense of one’s existence. Psychology likes things to be objective: observed, measured and run through statistical analysis. But the self is that something each of us actually lives. It is how we are, as perceived from the inside rather than observed from the outside.
During my decades in the therapy room I gradually came to realize the subjective lives of my clients didn’t fit the textbook theories very well. Certainly, I could see elements of the present self as a product of the past life of my clients. However, there was something else about them, something emerging and shifting. I observed the subjective sense of the client’s self as it engaged with their circumstances was changing. They were adapting better and becoming wiser. A different sense of one’s self was emerging.
This has made much more sense through a book I recently read, one in which British philosopher John Gray interpreted the writings of Isaiah Berlin. Berlin postulated that the self is under constant creation and does so through the value choices the person makes. Psychology had taught me that one’s choices were determined by one’s personality and circumstances. Berlin turned the directional arrow around to say our self arises from those value choices.
Berlin’s idea regarding the emergent nature of the self is a part of his analysis of freedom. We exercise freedom when we make choices between conflicting values. Each of us has a range of values motivating our choices and behaviours (e.g. loyalty to specific others or ideology, respect for authority or social conformity, and seeking personal security and satisfactions). However, life circumstances create dilemmas in which those values clash, requiring us to make a choice between which value to follow. As we consciously make that choice our sense of self emerges. Taking this a step further, the succession of choices contribute to the future self we become.
Let me illustrate…
If … and there eventually will be a “then” to this sentence… if we repeatedly choose to blame others when things go badly in our lives, seeing ourselves as victims, as powerless, entitled to something we don’t get to have, right when others who disagree are simply wrong, then … and here it comes! … then a characteristic self is created within us: a self that is discontented, outraged, aggressive, disrespectful.
Hmmm, I predict that you may be reading politics into this whole analysis. If you weren’t before reading that sentence, you probably are now.
Now, turn that if/then in the other direction. If the choices we make balance responsibility toward others with our own betterment, choosing gratitude rather than grievance, valuing kindness, generosity and grace, then … well, you fill in the likely self that would create.
So, let’s get back to the therapy room. For over four decades clients came to me emotionally suffering, struggling with relationships and adverse life circumstances. With understanding and compassion, with the safety and positive regard of the therapeutic relationship, when given respect for their autonomy and dignity, those clients began to make choices about how they would respond within their lives rather than just react to circumstances and others. When this was nurtured over a long enough course of psychotherapy a different sense of self emerged for the client. Their worlds weren’t so adverse anymore and they were more content.
Therapy wasn’t about getting a person “back to normal” after a period of disorder. It was about the creation of a new normal, one of greater wisdom and self-awareness. Their sense of self prior to the onset of their difficulties had been the matrix for the development of their problems. Returning them to back there shouldn’t be the goal. Therapy is not symptom management but letting a more adapted self emerge through repeated good choices.
Looking back on my own life I realize my sense of self has changed a lot. As a child and adolescent I would have defined my sense of self in terms of religion. My family’s engagement with a fundamentalist evangelical church was all encompassing. When I found my way into my career my sense of self became highly focused on being a psychotherapist, facilitating emotional stability and functionality to emerge in people’s lives. In retirement my sense of self focuses on creativity, safeguarding of my mental and physical resilience, and finding friendships I can deepen and make meaningful.
There are some commonalities across these three. From adolescence onward I’ve valued critical thought and not being swept along by the conventional perspectives surrounding me. There has always been recognition that kindness to others is important, consistently trying to be of a generous spirit.
But the transitions I made arose out of very deliberate value choices I would pursue. In acting on those choices my characteristic sense of self changed.
So getting back to the question. “So, just who do you think your are?”. There really should be the word “now” at the end before the question mark.
Furthermore, the question should also be stretched to include “Just who do you think you will be?” Based on the choices you’re making in the present, will the future you emerge as a better self or a bitter one?
Comments?